- Pain
- Paine
- Painton
- Pale
- Pallino
- Palmer
- Panec
- Panesh
- Sylvia (b. estimated 1914, d. 1994)
- Panton
- Ellen (b. about 1605, d. 1670)
- Pardue
- Park
- Parke
- Parker
- Parlin
- Parness
- Parret
- Parrish
- Parsons
- Parver
- Pascual
- Passmore
- Pate
- Patras
- Patrick
- Patten
- Patterson
- Paulson
- Pawner
- Payne
- Paynton
- Payson
- Mary (b. 1665, d. 1708)
- Susanna (b. 1655, d. (3 FEB 1737/8))
- Peabody
- Pearlman
- Pearson
- Peasley
- Peay
- Peddicord
- Pedersen
- Pehrsson
- Pennells,
- Penniman
- Perez
- Perkins
- Anne (d. 1623)
- Bathsna (b. 1605)
- Beatrice (b. 1570)
- Elizabeth (b. 1571)
- Elizabeth (b. 1643, d. after 1715)
- Frances (b. 1583, d. 1637)
- George (b. about 1538, d. 1586)
- Harington (b. 1615, d. 1619)
- Joan (b. 1571)
- John (b. 1608)
- John (b. 1655, d. 1712)
- Katherine (b. 1648, d. 1714)
- Marie (b. 1650)
- Mary (b. 1652)
- Rebecca (b. 1614, d. 1657)
- Rebecka (b. 1662, d. 1750)
- Ruth (b. 1617)
- Sarah (b. (2 MAR 1655/6), d. 1745)
- Sarah (b. 1612)
- Sarah (b. 1617, d. 1688)
- Thomas (b. 1576, d. 1637)
- Timothy (b. 1658, d. 1728)
- Tobijah (b. 1646, d. 1723)
- Toby (b. 1609, d. before 1657)
- William (b. 1578, d. 1657)
- William, (Reverend) (b. 1607, d. 1682)
- William (b. 1639, d. 1639)
- William (b. 1641, d. 1695)
- Perkol
- Perlak
- Perley
- Perlman
- Perry
- Perski
- Pesses
- Peterfreund
- Peterniova
- Peterson
- Petrover
- Pettingell
- Peverel
- Peverell
- Pfost
- Pharr
- Phelps
- Philippes
- Philips
- Phillips
- Pick
- Pickard
- Pickering
- Pickman
- Pickmann
- Pienkny
- Pierre
- Pieters
- Pijtters
- Pike
- Pildish
- Pinkoszewicz
- Pinsker
- Pitchon
- Plafker
- Plantagenet
- Plantagenet II
- Plashaletzky
- Platt
- Platts
- Plavin
- Plump
- Plumridge
- Poage
- Podsiadlik
- Pohl
- Pohlemann
- Polaner
- Polansky
- Pollan
- Poltun
- Polyakov
- Pomeranz
- Pool
- Poore
- Pope
- Popp
- Popple
- Porat
- Porter
- Porterfield
- Portman
- Portney
- Portnoy
- Post
- Potter
- Poyntz
- Poznanski
- Praer
- Prager
- Pratt
- Press
- Pressman
- Prestwick
- Preszziosi
- Price
- Pridmore
- Prince
- Prinz
- Probst
- Protextor
- Pruzanski
- Pryor
- Przedborski
- Przedborskich
- Puente
- Puffer
- Pulter
- Rose (b. about 1458, d. before 1522)
- Punt
- Purchase
- Aquila, Sr (b. 1588, d. 1633)
- Elizabeth (b. 1593)
- Ellen (b. 1598)
- Jane (b. 1584, d. 1633)
- Joan (b. 1578, d. 1653)
- John (b. 1594)
- Katherine (b. about 1538, d. 1626)
- Mary (b. 1583, d. 1639)
- Mary (b. about 1592, d. 1655)
- Oliver (b. 1550)
- Oliver, III (b. 1582, d. 1657)
- Oliver (b. about 1614, d. 1701)
- Pricilla (b. 1596)
- Robert (b. 1581)
- Sarah (b. about 1580, d. 1646)
- Thomas (b. 1577, d. 1678)
- Thomas (b. 1578, d. 1578)
- Purchis
- Puretz
- Puter
- Putman
- Agnes (b. 1505, d. before 1609)
- Putnam
- ?, (Miss.) (b. 1690)
- Abigail (b. 1700, d. 1764)
- Ann (b. 1645, d. 1676)
- Anne (b. 1578, d. 1630)
- Anne (b. 1589, d. 1678)
- Benjamin (b. 1629, d. 1700)
- Deliverance (b. 1656, d. 1699)
- Edward, (Deacon) (b. 1654, d. 1747)
- Edward, (Deacon) (b. 1682, d. 1755)
- Elisha (b. 1685, d. 1745)
- Elizabeth (b. 1578, d. 1639)
- Elizabeth (b. 1612, d. 1692)
- Elizabeth (b. 1659, d. 1727)
- Ezra (b. 1695, d. 1747)
- Holyoke (b. 1683, d. 1706)
- Isaac (b. 1698, d. 1757)
- Jeremiah (b. 1699, d. 1764)
- John, Sr. (d. 1662)
- John (b. 1617, d. 1620)
- John, Jr. (Captain) (b. 1627, d. 1710)
- Joseph (b. 1687, d. 1766)
- Lydia (b. 1684, d. 1711)
- Mary (b. 1649)
- Mary (b. 1689, d. 1726)
- Miriam (b. 1721)
- Nathaniel (b. 1619, d. 1700)
- Nehemiah (b. 1693, d. 1694)
- Nicholas (b. 1546, d. before 1598)
- Nicholas (b. 1582, d. 1607)
- Phoebe (b. 1624, d. 1630)
- Prudence (b. 1661, d. 1721)
- Prudence (b. 1692, d. 1753)
- Richard (b. 1586, d. 1607)
- Ruth (b. 1703, d. 1780)
- Sara (b. (7 MAR 1600 OR 1622))
- Sarah (b. 1648, d. 1648)
- Sarah (b. 1654, d. 1676)
- Thomas (b. about 1584, d. 1665)
- Thomas, (Lieut.) (b. 1615, d. 1686)
- Thomas, Jr. (b. 1652, d. 1699)
- William (b. 1592, d. 1592)